https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/31/us/p ... udges.html
.
White House Ends Bar Association’s Role in Vetting Judges
Judge Neil M. Gorsuch, President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, received the American Bar Association’s highest rating.
Judge Neil M. Gorsuch, President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, received the American Bar Association’s highest rating.Credit...Gabriella Demczuk for The New York Times
By Adam Liptak
March 31, 2017
WASHINGTON — The Trump administration has sent the American Bar Association into exile, ending the group’s semiofficial role in evaluating candidates for the federal bench.
In a statement on Friday announcing the development, Linda A. Klein, the group’s president, said it had provided prenomination evaluations of potential judicial candidates to every administration since that of Dwight D. Eisenhower, with the sole exception of that of George W. Bush.
The bar association recently gave its highest rating to Judge Neil M. Gorsuch, President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee. The administration and Republican senators have repeatedly relied on the endorsement as proof that Judge Gorsuch deserved to be confirmed.
Donald F. McGahn II, the White House counsel, notified the group of the decision to cut them out of the vetting process in a March 17 letter to Ms. Klein.
“Like previous administrations,” Mr. McGahn wrote, “we will release information regarding each nominee in a manner that provides equal access to all interested groups. But we do not intend to give any professional organizations special access to our nominees.”
Some studies have concluded that the bar association, a private trade group that often takes liberal positions, tends to favor the nominees of Democratic presidents.
In her statement, Ms. Klein said the A.B.A. had conducted “an objective, nonpartisan review of the professional competence, integrity and judicial temperament of those who would have lifetime appointments to our federal courts.”
Several prominent Republican appointees to federal appeals courts have received critical evaluations. Judges Richard A. Posner and Frank H. Easterbrook, both on the federal appeals court in Chicago; J. Harvie Wilkinson III, on the federal appeals court in Richmond, Va.; and Alex Kozinski, on the federal appeals court in San Francisco, all received mixed ratings.
In an interview on Friday, Judge Kozinski said his ratings had been particularly low. “I don’t see why one group in particular, all locked up by essentially big-firm lawyers, should have this special status,” he said.
Among other nominees of Republican presidents, Justice Clarence Thomas was given a split rating of “qualified” and “not qualified.” Judge Robert H. Bork, whose nomination was rejected by the Senate in 1987, received a curious decision, with the majority calling him “well qualified,” but four members saying he was “unqualified.”
Republicans have had less to complain about recently. Mr. Bush’s two appointees to the Supreme Court, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., both received the group’s highest rating.
“We do not give the ‘well qualified’ rating lightly,” Nancy Scott Degan, an official of the bar association, said last week at Judge Gorsuch’s confirmation hearings. The group had also given its highest rating to Judge Merrick B. Garland, President Barack Obama’s Supreme Court pick, whose confirmation proceedings were blocked by Senate Republicans.
Ms. Degan said the group’s evaluations were limited to candidates’ integrity, professional competence and judicial temperament. Ideology and politics were out of bounds, she said.
Amy Steigerwalt, a political scientist at Georgia State who has studied the A.B.A.’s role in judicial nominations, said she was surprised by the move. “There does seem to be in this administration a backing away from the establishment,” she said.
Ms. Klein of the A.B.A. said her group “will continue to provide its objective evaluations to the Senate Judiciary Committee as part of the judicial confirmation process.”
White House Ends Bar Association’s Role in Vetting Judges
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1500
- Joined: Sat Mar 31, 2018 11:38 pm
- County: Fairbanks
- Your State: Alive
- Contact:
White House Ends Bar Association’s Role in Vetting Judges
Unread post by Destry »
“First, let no one rule your mind or body. Take special care that your thoughts remain unfettered... . Give men your ear, but not your heart. Show respect for those in power, but don't follow them blindly. Judge with logic and reason, but comment not. Consider none your superior whatever their rank or station in life. Treat all fairly, or they will seek revenge. Be careful with your money. Hold fast to your beliefs and others will listen.”
“Wise? No, I simply learned to think.”
“Wise? No, I simply learned to think.”
Jump to
- Forum Rules
- New? Start Here!
- The word of God
- ↳ His Hard Line Scriptures
- National Assembly Blog
- For users who need passwords reset or users that do not receive emails.
- Outbound email blocking
- TEN STEPS TO AN ASSEMBLY BY WILL THEY MA'KIT
- Handbook For The Restoration of The Peaceful Sovereign States of America!
- 2018.05.10 Operation & Functions By-laws NAM Generic v.2
- 1638 Fundamental Orders
- Reba Live Red State Talk Radio explaining the foundation our assemblies stand on!
- Michigan Assembly Introduction Video
- Lapbook for home schooling
- His Hard Line Podcasts on Assembly
- Announcements and Notices
- Assembly Progress Reports
- National Assembly
- ↳ Notices in progress
- ↳ National Assembly Meeting Session Archive
- ↳ Requests for Agenda subjects
- ↳ Notice of voting on motions agenda for the next national assembly business meeting.
- ↳ National Assembly Seated Positions List
- ↳ National Assembly Documents and Resources
- ↳ National Assembly Meeting Motions De Jure Motion List History in Chronological Order
- State Assembly Support
- ↳ State Assembly Documents & Support
- ↳ State Assembly General Discussions
- County Assembly Support
- ↳ County Assembly Documents & Support
- ↳ County Assembly General Discussions
- General and off topic chat
- ↳ His Hard Line EDU Spot
- ↳ His Hard Line Quick Look
- ↳ HHL-Field Training Manual 2000-25 Series
- ↳ Voice of The People News Paper
- ↳ General Off Topic Chat
- ↳ Old Historical Documents
- ↳ Letters from an American farmer
- ↳ The Republic
- ↳ Video Library
- ↳ Legal Documents
- ↳ Resourceful Websites
- ↳ Humor
- ↳ Health and Healing
- ↳ In the Kitchen
- ↳ Alternative Energy and Hidden Tech.
- ↳ General News
- ↳ 5G microwave and the space fence
- ↳ Living Without the System by Clyde Edward Powell 22 DVD disk set
- ↳ Computers and Software
- ↳ Hoaxes and Scams
- The 50 Nation=States
- ↳ Alabama
- ↳ Alabama Introductions
- ↳ Alabama General Chat
- ↳ Alabama Historical Documents
- ↳ Alaska assembled settled
- ↳ Alaska Introductions
- ↳ Alaska General Chat
- ↳ Alaska's Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ Arizona
- ↳ Arizona Introductions
- ↳ Arizona General Chat
- ↳ Arizona's Historical Documents
- ↳ Arkansas Assembled
- ↳ Arkansas Introductions
- ↳ Arkansas General Chat
- ↳ Arkansas Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ California assembled questionable
- ↳ California Introductions
- ↳ California General Chat
- ↳ California's Historical Documents
- ↳ Colorado
- ↳ Colorado Introductions
- ↳ Colorado General Chat
- ↳ Colorado Historical Documents
- ↳ Connecticut
- ↳ Connecticut Intruductions
- ↳ Conneticut General Chat
- ↳ Connecticut's Historical Documents
- ↳ Delaware
- ↳ Delaware Introductions
- ↳ Delaware General Chat
- ↳ Delaware's Historical Documents
- ↳ Florida assembled
- ↳ Florida Introductions
- ↳ Florida General Chat
- ↳ Florida's Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ Georgia Assembled
- ↳ Georgia Introductions
- ↳ Georgia General Chat
- ↳ Georgia's Historical Documents
- ↳ Georgia Website
- ↳ Hawai'i assembled questionable
- ↳ Hawai'i Introductions
- ↳ Hawai'i General Chat
- ↳ Hawaii's Historical Documents
- ↳ Idaho
- ↳ Idaho Introductions
- ↳ Idaho General Chat
- ↳ Idaho's Historical Documents
- ↳ Illinois Assembled
- ↳ Illinois Introductions
- ↳ Illinois General Chat
- ↳ Illinois Historical Documents
- ↳ Indiana
- ↳ Indiana Introductions
- ↳ Indiana General Chat
- ↳ Indiana's Historical Documents
- ↳ Iowa
- ↳ Iowa Introductions
- ↳ Iowa General Chat
- ↳ Iowa's Historical Documents
- ↳ Kansas
- ↳ Kansas Introductions
- ↳ Kansas General Chat
- ↳ Kansas Historical Documents
- ↳ Kentucky assembled
- ↳ Kentucky Introductions
- ↳ Kentucky General Chat
- ↳ Kentucky Historical Documents
- ↳ Louisiana
- ↳ Louisiana Introductions
- ↳ Louisiana General Chat
- ↳ Louisiana Historical Documents
- ↳ Maine
- ↳ Maine Introductions
- ↳ Maine General Chat
- ↳ Maine Historical Documents
- ↳ Maryland
- ↳ Maryland Introductions
- ↳ Maryland General Chat
- ↳ Maryland Historical Documents
- ↳ Massachusetts
- ↳ Massachusetts Introductions
- ↳ Massachusetts General Chat
- ↳ Massachusetts Historical Documents
- ↳ Michigan assembled settled
- ↳ Michigan Introductions
- ↳ Michigan General Chat
- ↳ Michigan Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ Minnesota
- ↳ Minnesota Introductions
- ↳ Minnesota General Chat
- ↳ Minnesota Historical Documents
- ↳ Mississippi
- ↳ Mississippi Introductions
- ↳ Mississippi General Chat
- ↳ Mississippi Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ Missouri Assembled
- ↳ Missouri Introductions
- ↳ Missouri General Chat
- ↳ Missouri Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ Montana assembled questionable
- ↳ Montana Introductions
- ↳ Montana General Chat
- ↳ Montana Historical Documents
- ↳ Nebraska
- ↳ Nebraska Introductions
- ↳ Nebraska General Chat
- ↳ Nebraska Historical Documents
- ↳ Nevada
- ↳ Nevada Introductions
- ↳ Nevada General Chat
- ↳ Nevada Historical Documents
- ↳ New Hampshire
- ↳ New Hampshire Introductions
- ↳ New Hampshire General Chat
- ↳ New Hampshire Historical Documents
- ↳ New Jersey
- ↳ New Jersey Introductions
- ↳ New Jersey General Chat
- ↳ New Jersey Historical Documents
- ↳ New Mexico
- ↳ New Mexico Introductions
- ↳ New Mexico General Chat
- ↳ New Mexico Historical Documents
- ↳ New York assembled
- ↳ New York Introductions
- ↳ New York General Chat
- ↳ New York Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ North Carolina assembled
- ↳ North Carolina Introductions
- ↳ North Carolina General Chat
- ↳ North Carolina Historical Documents
- ↳ North Dakota assembled Questionable
- ↳ North Dakota Introductions
- ↳ North Dakota General Chat
- ↳ North Dakota Historical Documents
- ↳ Ohio
- ↳ Ohio Introductions
- ↳ Ohio General Chat
- ↳ Ohio Historical Documents
- ↳ Oklahoma
- ↳ Oklahoma Introductions
- ↳ Oklahoma General Chat
- ↳ Oklahoma Historical Documents
- ↳ Oregon Assembled
- ↳ Oregon Introductions
- ↳ Oregon General Chat
- ↳ Oregon Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ Pennsylvania
- ↳ Pennsylvania Introductions
- ↳ Pennsylvania General Chat
- ↳ Pennsylvania Historical Documents
- ↳ Rhode Island
- ↳ Rhode Island Introductions
- ↳ Rhode Island General Chat
- ↳ Rhode Island Historical Documents
- ↳ South Carolina
- ↳ South Carolina Introductions
- ↳ South Carolina General Chat
- ↳ South Carolina Historical Documents
- ↳ South Dakota
- ↳ South Dakota Introductions
- ↳ South Dakota General Chat
- ↳ South Dakota Historical Documents
- ↳ Tennessee Assembled
- ↳ Tennessee Introductions
- ↳ Tennessee General Chat
- ↳ Tennessee Historical Documents
- ↳ Texas
- ↳ Texas Introductions
- ↳ Texas General Chat
- ↳ Texas Historical Documents
- ↳ Utah
- ↳ Utah Introductions
- ↳ Utah General Chat
- ↳ Utah Historical Documents
- ↳ Vermont
- ↳ Vermont Introductions
- ↳ Vermont General Chat
- ↳ Vermont Historical Documents
- ↳ Virginia
- ↳ Virginia Introductions
- ↳ Virginia General Chat
- ↳ Virginia Historical Documents
- ↳ Washington
- ↳ Washington Introductions
- ↳ Washington General Chat
- ↳ Washington Historical Documents
- ↳ West Virginia
- ↳ West Virginia Introductions
- ↳ West Virginia General Chat
- ↳ West Virginia Historical Documents
- ↳ Wisconsin - Assembled
- ↳ Wisconsin Introductions
- ↳ Wisconsin General Chat
- ↳ Wisconsin Historical Documents
- ↳ Website
- ↳ Wyoming
- ↳ Wyoming Introductions
- ↳ Wyoming General Chat
- ↳ Wyoming Historical Documents
- International Community
- ↳ Australia
- ↳ Australia General Chat
- ↳ Australia History
- ↳ Canada
- ↳ Canada Introductions
- ↳ Canada General Chat
- ↳ Canada Historical Documents
- ↳ Germany
- ↳ Germany Introductions
- ↳ Germany General Chat
- ↳ Website
- ↳ Ireland
- ↳ Ireland Introductions
- ↳ Ireland General Chat
- ↳ Slovakia
- Suggestion Box